Gauteng Dominates Both Ends of New National Shopping Centre Rating Index

A comprehensive national analysis examining millions of user reviews across hundreds of retail spaces has revealed a stark geographical polarization within South Africa's commercial property sector, with Gauteng housing both the lowest-rated and highest-rated shopping centres in the country. Commercial property investors, asset managers, and leasing agents monitoring retail portfolio performance must take note of these sentiment metrics, which highlight significant disparities in tenant retention, foot traffic sustainability, and overall consumer perception across different nodes within the province. While several suburban retail properties continue to command exceptional consumer satisfaction scores, underperforming centres face severe reputational and operational challenges that directly impact their long-term commercial viability and asset value.

National Retail Rankings Reveal Deep Geographic Divides

The research initiative, conducted by SEO Backlinks, evaluated more than 3.2 million individual consumer ratings covering 678 retail destinations nationwide after filtering out closed facilities, traditional markets, individual storefronts, and office parks. Analysts focused exclusively on properties possessing a minimum threshold of 1 000 reviews to ensure statistical relevance, computing precise mathematical averages rather than relying on rounded platform scores. The resulting data exposed a worrying concentration of distressed retail assets, particularly in Gauteng, which accounts for eight of the 10 lowest-rated properties in the country. At the very bottom of the national table sits the Tshwane Shopping Mall located in Derdepoort, Pretoria, registering a dismal average rating of just 2.83 stars derived from 2 133 distinct consumer reviews. Other regional properties occupying the bottom tier include China Gate in Kempton Park, Jakaranda Centre in Pretoria, Morula Shopping Complex in Mabopane, Lesedi City Shopping Centre in Vosloorus, Home Africa Mall in Johannesburg, Naledi Mall in Vosloorus, and Batho Plaza in Soshanguve. Outside of Gauteng, only Kriel Mall in Mpumalanga and Cleary Park Shopping Centre in Gqeberha featured among the bottom 10 nationwide.

Operational Decline and Empty Shopfronts Drive Poor Consumer Sentiment

For commercial leasing professionals and property managers, the underlying drivers behind these poor ratings offer critical operational insights into why certain retail spaces struggle to retain tenants. Consumer feedback gathered across the lowest-rated properties frequently cited severe physical degradation over extended periods, with many facilities increasingly mirroring vacant ghost towns. Reviewers consistently highlighted structural and managerial failures, pointing specifically to high volumes of empty shopfronts, poorly maintained and unhygienic restroom facilities, and a general lack of proactive asset maintenance. According to SEO Backlinks founder Oliver Weston, tenant mix, parking accessibility, and cleanliness are paramount to modern shoppers. When landlords fail to maintain common areas, secure adequate parking, or curate a balanced retail and restaurant tenant schedule, customer dissatisfaction accelerates rapidly. This negative feedback loop directly harms foot traffic, making it increasingly difficult for remaining shop owners to generate sustainable turnover, which in turn leads to further lease cancellations and compounding vacancies across secondary retail portfolios.

High-Performing Gauteng Nodes Demonstrate Resilient Retail Demand

Despite the concentration of poorly rated assets, the province simultaneously anchors the upper echelon of the national retail market, hosting six of the country's 10 highest-rated shopping destinations. Melrose Arch in Johannesburg secured the second position nationally with an impressive average rating of 4.66 stars, closely followed by Nelson Mandela Square in Sandton at 4.63 stars. Additional top-performing Gauteng retail spaces identified in the study include The Neighbourhood Square in Linksfield, Loftus Park and Castle Gate in Pretoria, and Polofields Crossing situated in Waterfall. These high-scoring commercial properties demonstrate that well-managed, secure, and strategically curated retail environments continue to resonate strongly with consumers. For retail property investors and leasing executives, these contrasting findings underscore that location alone does not guarantee success; active property management, pristine facility maintenance, and targeted tenant curation remain the decisive factors separating thriving commercial spaces from distressed retail liabilities.

Source: The South African, 13 October 2026.

Get commercial property news by email

Free alerts when we publish — pick a focus or get everything, unsubscribe in one click. Subscribe »